Talk:Sholto/@comment-2601:600:9700:137:1DB6:7865:467B:65E4-20180614234317

The mistake was when Merry thought “three thousand years ago”. That was a typo. It should have said “three hundred years ago”. Then the information provided makes sense. If the War of the Dogs occurred over three hundred years ago, the sidthe would have been in Europe. When Merry guessed 500 years ago Rhys said she was off by two centuries. So 500 -200 = 300.

The three thousand years ago thing was a typo. A good editor would have spotted this and fixed it pronto.